Band members are:

Jordan Pundik Isaak (born October 12, 1979) is the singer of New Found Glory. He came up with the name of New Found Glory.

Chad Gilbert (born March 9, 1981 in Coral Springs, Florida) is the lead guitarist of the band and currently lives in Tyler (Texas). Before founding New Found Glory, he was the singer of metalcore band Shai Hulud. He also is a founding member of the hardcore punk band Hazen Street, and has together with band mate Ian Grushka the record label Broken Sounds.

Steve Klein (born September 30, 1979) is a founding member and rhythm guitarist of the band. Because he initially could not deal well with his guitar, he was thrown out, until he had learned to tune it properly.

Ian Grushka (born September 4, 1977 in Coral Springs, Florida) is the bassist of the band. Before he played with New Found Glory, he played with Jordan Pundik in the bands Flip 60, and  Inner City Kids. He also owns, along with bandmate Chad Gilbert, the record label Broken Sounds.

Cyrus Bolooki (born February 27, 1980) is the drummer. He joined New Found Glory, after they became aware of his skills at a talent show, and offered him the role on the drums.